It is pigmented and seriously glides over skin. The packaging is very uniform but still stays true to the brand. I like how easily I can control the amount of product I use as well as how easy to remove it is. I have never tried it in the waterline, in fact I am extremely boring beauty blogger who sticks to upper lash line :P
My only complaints would be that I have trouble sharpening it. I have tried both Chanel and NYX sharpeners but neither have worked well. Maybe if I just suck it up and buy the Urban Decay brand I will have better results. Is it just me or has anyone else had this issue too?